A sad night for the justice system

Courtesy / amnestyusa.org

I did not grow up with strong convictions about the death penalty.


To me, the whole messy topic seemed unpleasant and difficult, and I never fully formed an opinion. If I had to pick a side, I would have said that I vaguely supported it, but Troy Davis’s case, which came to an end tonight, helped plant me firmly into my newly-found anti-death penalty stance.


Tonight, the state of Georgia, the U.S. Supreme Court and the justice system as a whole made an egregious error by letting a potentially innocent man be put to death.


After 20 years of legal appeals, three stays of execution and a four-hour deliberation by the Supreme Court, death row inmate Davis was executed via lethal injection and pronounced dead at 11:08 p.m. despite significant doubt of his guilt.


What happened tonight was a disgusting example of how fatally flawed our justice system can be. I was stunned and appalled tonight as, after hours of tense consideration, the Supreme Court announced that they would not grant Davis a stay of execution. I was physically ill when his time of death was announced. Listening to the stunned silence of the crowds, my heart broke as I considered Davis’s family and Davis himself, who has maintained his innocence throughout the entire botched ordeal.


Davis was convicted in 1991 of the 1989 shooting of off-duty police officer Mark MacPhail based on the testimony of nine eyewitnesses, one of whom was inebriated at the time. Since the verdict, seven of those witnesses have signed affidavits recanting their testimonies, claiming that the Savannah police pressured them into providing testimony or that they did not remember the night well enough to say that Davis was without a doubt the killer. There was no forensic evidence tying Davis to the crime scene, and no murder weapon was ever discovered.


The amount of doubt present in Davis’s case was staggering, and when it comes to cases of capital punishment, any doubt is too much. When you strip the process of the legalese and the emotionless terminology such as “lethal injection” and “capital punishment,” it breaks down to murder for murder, “an eye for an eye,” and the process is just as barbaric now as it was thousands of years ago.


Read the full article at www.lanthorn.com.